I have a soft spot for S5 Angel because of the badassery of Illyria, in spite of how she arrived on scene. But I've only watched it once, so I don't know how it would hold up to rewatching. Considering how poorly all of Whedon's other shows do in retrospect, though …

BTW, I did start watching B5, all because of your recaps. I … um … watched up to a bit past this point in the space of about two weeks. I took a bit of a break (I can't imagine why!) and am just about ready to go back to it.