The fascists have already won
Nov. 3rd, 2018 11:36 amI wasn't here last night. I should have been, except that I'd have keeled over since after the week I've had, I didn't trust that I could actually stand up let alone dodge pepper spray. Much respect and love to the 12 comrades arrested and everyone doing courtroom support.
Macleans, of all the news sources in the world, gets it absolutely right, though their tone is more measured than I would use. The debate between David Frum and Steve Bannon is not a debate between liberal democracy and fascism, but the two wings of the modern far-right, a genocidal neoconservatism and a more thuggish brand of fascism.
This said, I disagree that the Munk Debates should have tried to find someone capable of destroying Bannon's arguments for the cause of liberal democracy. By allowing him to appear in public—by the mere fact that Bannon is allowed to cross the border into our country and collect a fat cheque for a public speaking engagement rather than spending his time hanging upside-down from a lamppost whilst schoolchildren play a game of football with his decomposing head—Bannon has already won. The fascists win when you invite them to the stage. That's their only goal; to be allowed to speak.
I have seen pictures of the audience as they went in. Surely some of them were in support, and a few brave others planned to disrupt (I don't know if they did) but the majority weren't Fred-Perry-wearing junior Brownshirts. No, they were the creme-de-la-creme of Canadian society, white, well-spoken, aging elites who probably clapped politely when the "debate" started 45 minutes late. What kind of person pays $40-100 to line the pockets of two of the worst people to slither from the swamp of fascist ideology? Did they stand in front of a full-length mirror, adjusting their ties, choosing the perfect broach? Did they congratulate themselves on their open-mindedness, their edginess, at their ability to listen to "both sides"?
Frum is the author of ISIS, responsible for turning the Middle East into a rising tide of blood. Bannon engineered the campaign and policies that have led to concentration camps for toddlers. In a just world, they would both have been shot by now. I'm not much more kindly inclined to anyone willing to indulge them in their grotesque games.
Macleans, of all the news sources in the world, gets it absolutely right, though their tone is more measured than I would use. The debate between David Frum and Steve Bannon is not a debate between liberal democracy and fascism, but the two wings of the modern far-right, a genocidal neoconservatism and a more thuggish brand of fascism.
This said, I disagree that the Munk Debates should have tried to find someone capable of destroying Bannon's arguments for the cause of liberal democracy. By allowing him to appear in public—by the mere fact that Bannon is allowed to cross the border into our country and collect a fat cheque for a public speaking engagement rather than spending his time hanging upside-down from a lamppost whilst schoolchildren play a game of football with his decomposing head—Bannon has already won. The fascists win when you invite them to the stage. That's their only goal; to be allowed to speak.
I have seen pictures of the audience as they went in. Surely some of them were in support, and a few brave others planned to disrupt (I don't know if they did) but the majority weren't Fred-Perry-wearing junior Brownshirts. No, they were the creme-de-la-creme of Canadian society, white, well-spoken, aging elites who probably clapped politely when the "debate" started 45 minutes late. What kind of person pays $40-100 to line the pockets of two of the worst people to slither from the swamp of fascist ideology? Did they stand in front of a full-length mirror, adjusting their ties, choosing the perfect broach? Did they congratulate themselves on their open-mindedness, their edginess, at their ability to listen to "both sides"?
Frum is the author of ISIS, responsible for turning the Middle East into a rising tide of blood. Bannon engineered the campaign and policies that have led to concentration camps for toddlers. In a just world, they would both have been shot by now. I'm not much more kindly inclined to anyone willing to indulge them in their grotesque games.